Civil Appeal Nos. 1345-1346 of 2009 & With Civil Appeal Nos. 1347-1348 of 2009. Case: 1. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., 2. Surendra Nath Loomba Vs 1. Surendra Nath Loomba and Others, 2. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. & ors.. Supreme Court (India)

Case NumberCivil Appeal Nos. 1345-1346 of 2009 & With Civil Appeal Nos. 1347-1348 of 2009
CounselFor Appellant: Meera Agarwal and Ramesh Chandra Mishra, Advs. for Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and For Respondents: A.T.M. Rangaramanujam, Sr. Adv., Vinod Wadhawani, M.A. Chinnasamy and M.A. Krishna Moorthy, Advs.
JudgesK. S. Radhakrishnan & Dipak Misra, JJ.
IssueMotor Vehicles Act, 1988 - Sections 166, 147 (b), 147, 149
Citation2012 (11) SCALE 134
Judgement DateNovember 20, 2012
CourtSupreme Court (India)

Judgment:

Digak Misra., J.

  1. In the present batch of appeals, two preferred by the Oriental Insurance Company Limited and two preferred by claimant, the assail is to the common judgment passed by the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in A.O. No. 201 of 2003 and A.O. No. 284 of 2003 wherein the award dated 19.5.2003 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Dehradun (for short 'the tribunal') in M.A.C.T. Petition No. 10 of 1999 was challenged by the insurer and the claimant from different spectrums.

  2. The facts which are requisite to be stated are that on 9.10.1998 about 4.30 a.m. claimant, Surendra Nath Loomba, was travelling 1n a Maruti Esteem Car bearing Registration No. DL 8C-5096 belonging to the respondent No. 3, Savita Matta, and driven by the respondent No. 2, Raj Loomba, the son of the claimant. Near the President Body guard House, Rajpur Road, the vehicle dashed against a tree and in the accident the windscreen (front) of car was smashed and its pieces got inserted into the eyes of the claimant as a consequence of which he lost his both eyes. As set forth, at the time of the accident the claimant was working as a Senior Manager in Punjab National Bank and his gross salary was Rs.18,949.86 per month and various perquisites were also attached to the service. Keeping in view his salary and other perquisites he filed an application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 before the tribunal putting forth a claim of Rs.62,00,000/- with 18 /o interest as compensation.

  3. The respondent No. 2, Raj Loomba, filed his written statement contending, inter alia, that at the time of accident the vehicle was insured with the Oriental Insurance Company Limited and hence, it being the insurer was liable to pay the compensation.

  4. The insurance company resisted the claim of the claimant on the ground that the driver of the vehicle did not have a valid driving licence; that the proceedings had been initiated in a collusive manner; and that even if the accident as well as the injuries were proven the insurer was not liable to indemnify the owner as the claimant was travelling as a gratuitous passenger.

  5. The tribunal on the basis of material brought on record came to hold that as the 1nsurer had issued Certificate of Insurance in respect of the vehicle in question and it was valid during the period when the accident occurred, it was liable to pay the compensation; that the opposite party No. 1 had a valid driving licence and the 4 accident had occurred and there was no collusion between the parties; and that the victim was entitled to get a total sum of Rs.20,97,984/- towards compensation with 9 /o interest per annum regard being had to the pecuniary and non-pecun1ary losses. Be it noted, the tribunal, while computing the amount, had deducted certain sum under certain heads which need not be stated in detail.

  6. Aggrieved by the aforesaid award the 1nsurance company preferred A.O. No. 201 of 2003 and the injured claimant preferred A.O. No. 284 of 2003 before the High Court. The High Court, by the common impugned order, reduced the amount of compensation to Rs.l6,42,656/- and concurred...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT