Case nº First Appeal Nos. 65 and 72 of 2008 of National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, May 22, 2013 (case 1. G.K. Sabharwal and Smt. Jaishree Sabharwal, 2. Dr. Rajiv Chawla and Santom Hospital Vs 1. Dr. Satish Virmani, MBBS and Ors., 2. G.K. Sabharwal & Smt. Jaishree Sabharwal, Dr. Satish Virmani, Dr. Randhir Sood and Sir Ganga Ram Hospital)

JudgeFor Appellant: Mr. Sunil Malhotra, Advocate with Mr. G.K. Sabharwal, for Appellants in FA/65/2008 & R-1 in FA72/2008 and Mr. Neeraj Jain, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Roohi Kohli, Adv. and Mr. Pradhan, Advocate, for Appellants in FA/72/2008 & R-2 & 3 in FA/65/2008 and For Respondents: Mr. Vipin Jai, Advocate, for R-1 in FA/65/2008 & R-2 in FA/72/2008...
PresidentAshok Bhan, President and Vineeta Rai, Member
Resolution DateMay 22, 2013
Issuing OrganizationNational Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission

Order:

Vineeta Rai, Member

1. First Appeal No. 65 of 2008 has been filed by Shri G.K. Sabharwal and another, Original Complainants before the Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (hereinafter referred to as the State Commission) being aggrieved by the order of that Commission, which had granted them lesser compensation of Rs. 50,000/- and Rs. 10,000/- towards litigation costs against their claim of Rs. 20,00,000/- and dismissed the complaint of medical negligence against OPs No. 1, 4 and 5.

First Appeal No. 72 of 2008 has been filed by Dr. Rajiv Chawla and Santom Hospital, OPs No. 2 and 3 before the State Commission, being aggrieved by its order holding them guilty of negligence in not conducting proper investigations in the medical treatment and directing them to jointly and severally pay the Complainants a lump-sum compensation of Rs. 50,000/- alongwith Rs. 10,000/- as costs. Since the facts and the parties in both appeals are common arising out of the same consumer complaint, it is proposed to dispose of these appeals by a common order by taking the facts from First Appeal No. 65 of 2008. The parties will be referred to in the manner in which they were referred to in the complaint i.e. Shri G.K. Sabharwal and Smt. Jaishree Sabharwal as Complainants, Dr. Satish Virmani as OP-1, Dr. Rajiv Chawla as OP-2, Santom Hospital as OP-3, Dr. Ranghir Sood as OP-4 and Sir Ganga Ram Hospital as OP-5.

In their complaint before the State Commission, Complainants had contended that their daughter Miss Sonal Sabharwal (hereinafter referred to as the Patient) aged about 19 years was running a fever of 103 on 03.10.1997 and was taken for medical treatment to one Dr. Satish Virmani/OP-1, who gave her medication and advised blood tests for Malaria, Hepatitis, Typhoid etc. The tests were negative for Malaria, Bilurubin as also Typhoid but since platelet counts were below normal limits, and Patient's condition did not improve, OP-1 advised Complainants to take her to OP-2, who was a Specialist. After examination of the Patient, OP-2 advised the Complainants to admit the Patient to Santom Hospital/OP-3 for necessary investigations and treatment. It was contended that although the blood tests conducted there were again negative for Malaria, all other symptoms, including very low platelet counts and high temperature were clearly indicative of Malaria but OP-2 did not give any medication for Malaria and on the other hand diagnosed it to be a case of viral hepatitis, for which treatment was given to the Patient till she was shifted to Sir Ganga Ram Hospital/OP5. Even in that hospital, there was delay on the part of OP-4 (Doctor of OP-5/Hospital) in starting the treatment since the Patient was brought at 8.30 a.m. on 07.10.1997 and by the time her treatment was started, her platelet counts had come down to 48000. She was detected with Cerebral Malaria at a very late stage and even though Mefloquine was administered, it was too late. Patient was not put on life support nor was she taken to ICU. Because of the negligence on the part of all the OPs, the Patient could not be saved. Being aggrieved, Complainants filed a complaint before the State Commission requesting that they be awarded compensation of Rs. 20,00,000/- with interest @ 24% per annum from the date of death of the Patient till realization for the irreparable loss suffered by them.

2. OPs on being served filed their...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT