Extract
Monika Ranka & Ors. VS. Medical Council Of India & Ors.
The Judgement Information System REPORTABLEIN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACIVIL APPELALTE JURISDICTIONCIVIL APPEAL NO. 3303 of 2005 Indian Bank Versus Godhara Nagrik Cooperative Credit Society Ltd. and another WITH (C.A. Nos. 3336, 3337, 3338 and 3304-3335 of 2005)JUDGMENTS.B. SINHA, J.1. These appeals involve an interesting question as regards the power of judicial review of a Superior Court.2 herein are cooperative societies registered under the Cooperative Societies Act and/or their Members. 2 They deposited certain amounts in cash in fixed deposits of Banks wherefor Fixed Deposit Receipts (FDRs) were to be issued. Such deposits were made through some so-called Commission Agents of the Banks on payment of huge commission which is ordinarily not allowed by the Nationalized Banks.3. Applications for grant of loans by various persons were filed before the prescribed authorities of the banks on the basis of the said FDRs.Allegedly a large number of officers of the banks were involved in a scam whereby unofficial investments of the said amount were being made.4. As and when the FDRs matured, the investors requested the Banks for their encashment. The banks refused to accede thereto stating that the amount under the FDRs had already been paid by way of loans and, thus, no further amount was payable. It was contended that a fraud on the banks has been practiced to which the depositors and the officers of the banks were parties.5. Writ petitions were filed. A learned Single Judge of the High Court opined that serious disputed questions of fact being involved in the said writ petitions, no relief can be granted to the writ petitioners. 3 6. Despite the same, the learned single judge relying on the provisions contained in Secti...
See the full content of this document