S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14795/2010. Case: Dr. Rang Lal Meena Vs Raj. Civil Services Appellate Tribunal and Ors.. Rajasthan High Court

Case NumberS.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 14795/2010
JudgesAjay Rastogi, J.
IssueConstitution of India - Article 226
Judgement DateNovember 02, 2010
CourtRajasthan High Court

Judgment:

Ajay Rastogi, J., (Jaipur Bench)

  1. Instant petition has been filed by the Petitioner assailing the order dt.27.10.2010 whereby the learned Tribunal declined to grant interim relief.

  2. It appears from the record that petitioner was transferred vide order dt.03.09.2010 and the learned Tribunal after examination of the material on record issued notice of appeal but was not inclined to grant interim order as prayed for.

  3. Counsel submits that the reason assigned by the learned Tribunal declining to grant interim order is not sustainable in law and the same requires interference by this Court.

  4. The learned Tribunal after examination of the material on record while calling upon the Respondents was not inclined to grant interim relief as prayed for and merely because the interim order has not been granted to the Petitioner that itself is not sufficient to interfere by this Court unless the order is arbitrary or there being an allegation imputing malice. Which is not the case of the petitioner.

  5. However counsel submits that in the ordinary course the Appellant would never have advised to approach this Court by filing writ petition against the order declining to grant interim relief by the Tribunal but since the the appeals are not being heard expeditiously particularly relating to transfer, in absence whereof the very purpose of filing appeal becomes redundant and their right of hearing is prejudiced. He has further informed to this Court that the learned Tribunal takes only 60 matters in a day for admission and there is huge pendency of almost 1400 appeals pertaining to transfers and if in the present scenario it remains so, their statutory and legitimate right under the Act of 1976 in fact becomes totally frustrated.

  6. This...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT